Online Community Managers bubble
Online Community Managers profile
Online Community Managers
Bubble
Professional
Online Community Managers are professionals dedicated to cultivating, moderating, and growing online communities using specific strateg...Show more
General Q&A
Online community managers cultivate, moderate, and grow digital communities by balancing user engagement, platform health, and organizational goals, often working behind the scenes to set the tone and resolve conflicts.
Community Q&A

Summary

Key Findings

Conflict Craft

Social Norms
Online Community Managers deeply value emotional labor and skillfully perform behind-the-scenes conflict resolution, balancing empathy with strict enforcement to maintain community health.

Status Stories

Identity Markers
Insider status hinges on war stories from crisis management or viral events, showcasing expertise in both human dynamics and platform technicalities.

Tool Fluency

Insider Perspective
Community Managers master unique insider jargon like 'banhammer' and 'thread necromancy', reflecting specialized workflows and signaling deep platform understanding.

Invisible Work

Hidden Influences
Much of their labor is behind-the-scenes, misunderstood by outsiders who often see moderation as censorship rather than a nuanced mix of strategy, empathy, and culture-building.
Sub Groups

Platform-Specific Managers

Managers specializing in communities on platforms like Discord, Facebook, Reddit, or Slack.

Strategy & Analytics Specialists

Community managers focused on metrics, engagement strategies, and data-driven growth.

Industry-Focused Managers

Managers working within specific industries (gaming, tech, education, etc.) with unique community needs.

Freelance & Agency Managers

Independent professionals or those working for agencies managing multiple client communities.

Statistics and Demographics

Platform Distribution
1 / 3
Slack
30%

Slack is widely used by online community managers for professional networking, sharing best practices, and real-time collaboration in private or semi-private channels.

Slack faviconVisit Platform
Messaging & Chat
online
Discord
20%

Discord hosts numerous servers dedicated to community management, offering spaces for peer support, resource sharing, and live discussion.

Discord faviconVisit Platform
Discussion Forums
online
LinkedIn
15%

LinkedIn groups and professional networks are central for community managers to connect, share industry news, and discuss trends.

LinkedIn faviconVisit Platform
Professional Networks
online
Gender & Age Distribution
MaleFemale45%55%
18-2425-3435-4445-5455-6465+15%50%23%8%3%1%
Ideological & Social Divides
Hands-on ModsStrategy LeadsInnovation LabWorldview (Traditional → Futuristic)Social Situation (Lower → Upper)
Community Development

Insider Knowledge

Terminology
ModeratorCommunity Manager

Outsiders frequently use 'moderator' to label anyone who enforces rules, but insiders distinguish 'community managers' as strategic leaders beyond simple moderation.

PostContent Piece

Casual observers say 'post' for any shared item, whereas insiders use 'content piece' to reflect intentional creation and curation.

Likes and SharesEngagement Metrics

Casual observers focus on visible reactions like likes and shares, whereas managers refer broadly to 'engagement metrics' which guide community growth strategies.

Report ButtonFlagging System

General users say 'report button,' while community members use 'flagging system' highlighting the process of identifying and reviewing problematic content.

UserMember

While outsiders refer to participants as 'users,' community managers prefer 'members' to emphasize community belonging and identity.

FollowerSubscriber

While outsiders call audience members 'followers,' community managers prefer 'subscribers' to emphasize active, consent-based participation.

Banned UserSuspended Member

Casual observers say 'banned user' implying permanent exclusion, whereas community managers use 'suspended member' which may be temporary and subject to appeal.

Comment SectionThread

Outsiders often call conversations 'comment sections,' whereas insiders refer to individual conversation chains as 'threads' to highlight structure and continuity.

SpamToxic Content

Casual observers broadly label unwanted posts as 'spam,' but community managers distinguish harmful behavior as 'toxic content' to better address moderation and community health.

DeleteRemove

Outsiders say 'delete' to mean content removal, but managers often prefer 'remove' to imply moderation action within community guidelines.

Greeting Salutations
Example Conversation
Insider
Welcome to the Hive!
Outsider
Huh? What do you mean by that?
Insider
‘The Hive’ is our affectionate term for the community — it’s lively like a beehive, and ‘Buzzing with excitement’ is how we greet newcomers warmly.
Outsider
Oh, that’s clever! I like that.
Cultural Context
This greeting uses metaphorical language to evoke a sense of energetic community life and solidarity.
Inside Jokes

"Did someone just necro a 5-year-old thread?"

This is joked about because reviving very old threads can either spark great insights or annoy members, reflecting a common dilemma community managers face.

"Deploying the banhammer!"

Used humorously when a moderator bans a user, this phrase lightens the mood around a serious action.
Facts & Sayings

Thread necromancy

The act of resurrecting an old forum thread or discussion, often to bring back valuable insights or address unresolved issues.

Banhammer

A humorous term referring to the moderator's power to ban users who violate community rules.

Engagement ladder

A conceptual model describing stages that community members progress through as they become more involved and active contributors.

Content cadence

The planned rhythm or frequency of content being posted to maintain community interest and participation.
Unwritten Rules

Never publicly argue with members.

Maintaining professionalism preserves community trust and avoids escalating conflicts.

Respond promptly but thoughtfully.

Timely replies show respect to community members but hasty responses risk miscommunication.

Balance transparency with brand policies.

Being open fosters trust, but some information must stay confidential to protect the community and company.

Know when to escalate issues.

Some complex conflicts require involving legal or higher management rather than handling alone.
Fictional Portraits

Maya, 29

Community Managerfemale

Maya has been managing gaming communities for four years and specializes in creating inclusive, engaging spaces for diverse player bases.

InclusivityTransparencyProactive communication
Motivations
  • Building safe and welcoming spaces
  • Driving meaningful member engagement
  • Measuring community growth and success
Challenges
  • Handling toxic behavior and conflict resolution
  • Balancing automation tools with human interaction
  • Keeping up with rapidly changing platform policies
Platforms
Discord serversTwitter threadsSlack workspaces
engagement ratemoderation queuemember churn

Carlos, 42

Freelance Moderatormale

Carlos manages multiple niche hobbyist forums as a freelancer, balancing client expectations with community needs across platforms.

ResponsibilityNeutralityEfficiency
Motivations
  • Maintaining order and civility
  • Facilitating niche interest discussions
  • Delivering results to clients
Challenges
  • Time management across multiple communities
  • Limited resources for moderation
  • Dealing with client pressure for rapid growth
Platforms
Reddit modmailTelegram groupsEmail
shadowbanflairsticky post

Nina, 24

Social Media Managerfemale

Nina integrates community management with social media strategy for a startup, focusing on brand reputation and member engagement across platforms.

AuthenticityCreativityResponsiveness
Motivations
  • Growing brand loyalty through community
  • Creating viral, relatable content
  • Harnessing member feedback for product improvement
Challenges
  • Aligning community goals with marketing objectives
  • Handling negative feedback publicly
  • Managing cross-platform engagement effectively
Platforms
Instagram commentsFacebook groupsSlack channels
engagement podssentiment analysisbrand evangelist

Insights & Background

Historical Timeline
Main Subjects
Concepts

Community Engagement

Techniques and frameworks for driving active participation and loyalty.
Interaction FocusRetention Core

Moderation

Rules, roles, and tooling to maintain healthy discourse and enforce community standards.
Risk MitigationTrust Builder

Member Onboarding

Processes and touchpoints for integrating new members into community culture.
First ImpressionsWelcome Flow

Community Lifecycle

Stages from launch to maturity, guiding growth strategy and resource allocation.
Growth FrameworkStage-Based

Community Metrics

KPIs like DAU, engagement rate, and sentiment analysis for measuring success.
Data-DrivenPerformance Indicators

Content Strategy

Planning and scheduling of posts, campaigns, and value-driven resources.
Editorial PlanValue Delivery

Gamification

Use of rewards, badges, and challenges to motivate member participation.
Motivation HackReward Systems

Community Guidelines

Published rules and norms that set expectations for member behavior.
Behavioral CompassCulture Charter

Peer Support

Structures enabling members to help each other, reducing staff load.
Crowd HelpEmpowerment

Crisis Management

Protocols for handling PR issues, conflicts, or platform outages.
Incident ResponseReputation Guard
1 / 3

First Steps & Resources

Get-Started Steps
Time to basics: 3-4 weeks
1

Observe Active Communities

1 weekBasic
Summary: Join and quietly observe 2-3 thriving online communities to study their management styles.
Details: Start by joining a few well-moderated online communities (forums, Discord servers, Facebook groups, etc.) as a silent observer. Pay close attention to how moderators interact, enforce rules, and foster engagement. Take notes on community guidelines, tone, onboarding processes, and how conflicts are handled. Avoid jumping into moderation discussions immediately; instead, focus on understanding the community’s culture and the subtle ways managers shape it. Common beginner mistakes include being too eager to participate without understanding context, or missing the nuances of community tone. To overcome this, spend at least a week observing before interacting. This step is crucial because it grounds your understanding in real-world practice, not just theory. Evaluate your progress by being able to articulate the differences in management style and culture between the communities you observe.
2

Study Community Guidelines

2-3 hoursBasic
Summary: Analyze published rules and guidelines from established communities to learn best practices.
Details: Collect and read the published rules, codes of conduct, and onboarding documents from several established online communities. Compare how different communities articulate their values, set boundaries, and communicate expectations. Look for patterns in language, structure, and enforcement policies. Beginners often overlook the importance of clear, accessible guidelines or fail to notice how rules reflect a community’s goals. To avoid this, create a comparison chart or notes on what works well and what feels unclear. This step is vital because writing and enforcing guidelines is a core skill for community managers. Progress can be measured by your ability to draft a sample set of guidelines for a hypothetical community, incorporating best practices you’ve observed.
3

Engage in Community Discussions

1 weekIntermediate
Summary: Participate thoughtfully in discussions, focusing on positive engagement and conflict resolution.
Details: After observing, begin participating in discussions within your chosen communities. Aim to model positive engagement: ask questions, offer help, and respond constructively. Pay special attention to how moderators and managers handle disputes or off-topic posts, and try to emulate their tone and approach. Beginners sometimes overstep by acting like moderators or by misunderstanding community norms. To avoid this, always defer to existing moderators and focus on being a supportive member. This step is important because it builds empathy for members and helps you understand the challenges of maintaining a healthy environment. Evaluate your progress by reflecting on feedback from others and noting any changes in how your contributions are received.
Welcoming Practices

Onboarding AMA (Ask Me Anything) sessions

New community members get to ask questions directly to managers or veteran members, helping them feel included and informed early on.

‘First post’ shoutouts

Acknowledging a newcomer’s initial contribution encourages continued participation and builds rapport.
Beginner Mistakes

Jumping in to correct or reprimand members publicly.

Use private messages or official channels when addressing issues to maintain trust and avoid public embarrassment.

Focusing solely on visible engagement metrics.

Pay attention to qualitative data like member sentiment and feedback to get a fuller picture of community health.
Pathway to Credibility

Tap a pathway step to view details

Facts

Regional Differences
North America

North American community managers often emphasize data analytics and ROI-driven strategies, reflecting the corporate focus on measurable impact.

Europe

European communities may have stricter privacy and consent norms affecting moderation styles and member communications.

Asia

In Asia, community managers may handle platforms with distinct cultural etiquettes and sometimes more hierarchical member structures, influencing engagement tactics.

Misconceptions

Misconception #1

Community managers are just moderators who censor content.

Reality

Their role blends conflict resolution, strategic growth, member engagement, and often involves emotional labor beyond simple moderation.

Misconception #2

Community managers and social media managers have the same job.

Reality

While overlapping, community managers focus deeply on building and nurturing communities, managing culture and member relationships, not just content scheduling and brand promotion.
Clothing & Styles

Branded T-shirts or hoodies

Community managers often wear apparel featuring their community or platform’s branding at industry events to signal their professional identity and foster networking.

Feedback

How helpful was the information in Online Community Managers?