Supernatural Fanfiction bubble
Supernatural Fanfiction profile
Supernatural Fanfiction
Bubble
Skill
Supernatural Fanfiction is a vibrant online community where fans of the TV series 'Supernatural' write, share, and critique original st...Show more
General Q&A
It's about fans of the TV show Supernatural creating and sharing stories that expand, reinterpret, or diverge from the show's original universe, often exploring new adventures, relationships, or alternate outcomes.
Community Q&A

Summary

Key Findings

Ship Wars

Polarization Factors
Intense debates over ships like Destiel and Wincest deeply divide members, shaping social alignments and creating underground hierarchies based on shipping allegiance within the community.

Beta Rituals

Identity Markers
The role of beta readers is sacred and highly ritualized, with trusted betas gaining insider status for shaping story quality and preserving community standards.

Canon Fluidity

Insider Perspective
Canon is treated as flexible, with canon divergence and fix-it fic allowing members to negotiate and contest official storylines creatively, maintaining dynamic community boundaries.

Event Culture

Community Dynamics
Collective writing events like Big Bang challenges and prompt memes foster strong group identity and creative momentum, serving as social glue beyond just fanfic creation.
Sub Groups

Destiel Writers

Fans who focus on stories about the Dean/Castiel pairing, often forming their own writing circles and events.

Canon Divergence Authors

Writers who explore alternate storylines diverging from the show's canon, often engaging in deep discussion and collaborative projects.

Beta Readers & Editors

Community members who specialize in editing and providing feedback on fanfiction drafts.

Convention Meetup Groups

Fans who organize or attend in-person gatherings at Supernatural conventions to discuss and celebrate fanfiction.

Statistics and Demographics

Platform Distribution
1 / 3
Reddit
30%

Reddit hosts large, active subreddits dedicated to Supernatural fanfiction, where fans share stories, discuss tropes, and provide feedback.

Reddit faviconVisit Platform
Discussion Forums
online
Discord
20%

Discord servers offer real-time chat, writing sprints, and community events specifically for Supernatural fanfiction writers and readers.

Discord faviconVisit Platform
Discussion Forums
online
Niche Forums
15%

Independent fanfiction forums and message boards have long been central to the Supernatural fanfiction community, supporting deep discussion and archiving works.

Discussion Forums
online
Gender & Age Distribution
MaleFemale20%80%
13-1718-2425-3435-4445-5455-6465+15%40%30%10%3%1%1%
Ideological & Social Divides
Lore GuardiansCrossover ArtistsEvent CatalystsWorldview (Traditional → Futuristic)Social Situation (Lower → Upper)
Community Development

Insider Knowledge

Terminology
SummaryAuthor's Note (AN)

Insiders often include an 'Author's Note' appended to stories, a term and convention not commonly recognized by casual observers.

Character BackstoryCanon Divergence

'Canon divergence' is an insider term describing plots that intentionally differ from the original storyline, a nuance outsiders usually miss.

Cross-Over StoryCrossover

Outsiders say cross-over story, but insiders use 'crossover' as a single compound word to denote stories combining multiple universes or fandoms.

Fan FictionFic

Outsiders refer to stories based on the show simply as fan fiction, while insiders abbreviate it as 'fic', which is a common shorthand within the community.

Deleted SceneMissing Scene

Fans use 'missing scene' to describe added content that fills in gaps in the original show, differing from outsiders who might just say deleted scene.

Episode RecapRecap

While outsiders might say episode recap, insiders shorten it to 'recap', reflecting frequent discussion and analysis within the fandom.

ShippingShip

Non-members use 'shipping' as a verb generally, whereas members use 'ship' as both a verb and noun to refer specifically to their favorite character pairings.

Story UpdateChapter Drop

Insiders say 'chapter drop' to refer to a new story installment being posted, emphasizing the episodic nature of fanfiction updates.

Plot TwistAU (Alternate Universe)

Fans often create 'AUs' that drastically change the story's world, a concept outsiders may only refer to as plot twists or variations more generally.

Original CharacterOC

Outsiders may say original character fully, but fans use the abbreviation 'OC' as a standard term for fan-created characters in stories.

Greeting Salutations
Example Conversation
Insider
Hey! How's the hunt?
Outsider
Huh? What do you mean by 'hunt'?
Insider
It's a playful way we greet each other, referencing the show's monster hunting theme. It means 'How are you doing?'
Outsider
Oh, that's clever! Fits perfectly with the community vibe.
Cultural Context
This greeting connects fans by referencing the central activity of Supernatural, hunting monsters, and is a casual way to check in.
Inside Jokes

"Dean's love for pie is bigger than his love life."

A running community joke referencing Dean Winchester's recurring obsession with pie on the TV show, humorously contrasting his often complicated romantic relationships.

"No Cas, no canon."

This joke underscores how integral Castiel is to many fanfics and fans’ understanding of the show's storyline, even though he wasn’t part of the original first seasons.
Facts & Sayings

Destiel

An abbreviation for the romantic pairing of Dean Winchester and Castiel; frequently referenced in fic titles and discussions to signal stories focused on this ship.

Wincest

A controversial ship between brothers Sam and Dean Winchester, often a topic of heated debates within the community.

Canon divergence

A term describing fics that branch off from established TV show events, creating alternate timelines or outcomes.

Fix-it fic

Stories written to 'fix' or offer alternate solutions to unhappy or problematic plot developments in the TV series.

Case fic

Fanfiction focusing specifically on standalone monster-hunting episodes or cases, mimicking the episodic structure of the show.
Unwritten Rules

Always tag your fic thoroughly, especially with ships and triggers.

Proper tagging helps readers find suitable content and prevents accidental exposure to sensitive material, fostering community trust.

Give constructive feedback when beta reading.

Detailed, kind critique is expected; blunt or harsh comments are discouraged as they can discourage writers.

Respect author's canon choices even if you disagree.

Even if a story diverges from the TV show’s canon or interprets characters differently, it’s important to engage respectfully to maintain a welcoming environment.

Participate in community events like Big Bangs or prompt memes to build connections.

Joining collaborative challenges signals commitment and integration into the community culture.
Fictional Portraits

Emma, 22

College Studentfemale

Emma is an English literature student who discovered the Supernatural fanfiction community during her first year at university and quickly became an active creator and discussion participant.

CreativityCommunity SupportRespect for Canon
Motivations
  • Express creativity through writing
  • Connect with fellow fans of Supernatural
  • Improve storytelling skills
Challenges
  • Balancing study and entertaining fanfiction writing
  • Finding constructive critiques for her stories
  • Navigating spoilers within the community
Platforms
Supernatural subredditsAO3 commentsDiscord writing groups
OCcanon divergenceship

Carlos, 35

IT Specialistmale

Carlos is a longtime Supernatural fan who uses fanfiction as a relaxing escape and enjoys participating mainly as a reader and reviewer rather than a writer.

QualitySupportivenessCritical Thinking
Motivations
  • Find quality fanfiction to enjoy
  • Support new writers with constructive feedback
  • Relive and deepen connection to the Supernatural universe
Challenges
  • Keeping up with a large volume of new stories
  • Finding fanfiction that aligns with his preferences
  • Avoiding toxic forum debates
Platforms
Reddit Supernatural fanfic threadsFanfiction comment sections
ShipHurt/ComfortCanon compliant

Nina, 29

Freelance Writerfemale

Nina is a published fiction author who occasionally participates in the Supernatural fanfiction community to experiment with character development and engage with other serious writers.

ArtistryProfessionalismAuthenticity
Motivations
  • Practice new writing styles in a low-pressure environment
  • Network with other skilled writers
  • Challenge common fanfiction clichés
Challenges
  • Maintaining professional privacy while engaging publicly
  • Finding equally skilled collaborators and critics
  • Balancing fanfiction with paid writing projects
Platforms
Private Discord channelsAO3 beta reading groups
Beta readerMary SuePlot bunnies

Insights & Background

Historical Timeline
Main Subjects
Works

Carry On

A sprawling Destiel epic by LadyMerlin that set new benchmarks for length, character depth, and world-building in Supernatural fanfic.
Destiel EpicCharacter-DrivenCanon Divergence

The Innocence of Gabriel

A Michael/Gabriel fic by ApollyonIcarus notable for nuanced archangel characterization and theological themes.
Angelology FocusTheological DepthSlash

On My Side

Volled’s Winchester-centric AU that explores moral ambiguity and brotherhood outside the standard hunting framework.
Bro/Pact AUMoral AmbiguityBrotherhood

Long Division

A comedy-driven fic by apiratealways highlighting Sam and Dean’s sibling banter and roadside shenanigans.
HumorRoadtripSibling Dynamics

Day of the Dead

CalicoBeatle’s crossover with zombie lore, lauded for suspense and genre-blending flair.
CrossoverHorror TwistGenre Mashup

Three Sheet to the Wind

MeredithP’s exploration of Dean’s grief-and-recovery arc, a seminal hurt/comfort work.
Hurt/ComfortCharacter HealingEmotional Journey

A Tested Heart

Aileen-K’s story built around ritual magic rituals and familial sacrifice, expanding on series lore.
Magic RitualFamily DramaDark Themes
1 / 3

First Steps & Resources

Get-Started Steps
Time to basics: 2-3 weeks
1

Read Popular Fanfiction Stories

2-3 hoursBasic
Summary: Explore top-rated Supernatural fanfics to understand styles, tropes, and community expectations.
Details: Begin by immersing yourself in the world of Supernatural fanfiction. Search for highly recommended or most-read stories on major fanfiction platforms. Pay attention to the variety of genres (e.g., casefic, AU, fluff, angst), common tropes, and how writers handle characters and canon. Take notes on what you enjoy, what feels true to the show, and how stories are structured. This step helps you internalize the tone, pacing, and conventions valued by the community. Beginners often skim without engaging deeply—try to read thoughtfully, noting what works and what doesn’t. This foundational exposure will inform your own writing and participation. Evaluate your progress by feeling comfortable discussing favorite stories and identifying recurring themes or tropes.
2

Join Fanfiction Community Spaces

1-2 daysBasic
Summary: Register and introduce yourself in Supernatural fanfiction forums or social groups to observe and connect.
Details: Find online spaces dedicated to Supernatural fanfiction—these may be forums, Discord servers, or social media groups. Register an account, read the rules, and introduce yourself in designated threads. Observe ongoing discussions, community events, and etiquette. Engage by commenting on posts or asking questions about getting started. Many beginners hesitate to interact, fearing judgment; remember, most communities welcome newcomers and offer guidance. This step is crucial for understanding unwritten norms, finding support, and building connections. Progress is marked by feeling comfortable posting, recognizing regular members, and understanding community culture.
3

Review and Leave Constructive Feedback

2-4 hoursIntermediate
Summary: Comment thoughtfully on stories you read, focusing on what you liked and why, to engage with writers and readers.
Details: After reading stories, take the time to leave meaningful comments or reviews. Go beyond generic praise—mention specific elements you enjoyed (characterization, dialogue, plot twists) and explain why. This not only encourages writers but also helps you practice critical reading and analysis. Beginners often worry about saying the wrong thing; focus on being positive and specific, and avoid unsolicited criticism. Engaging in this way builds your reputation as a thoughtful community member and may lead to reciprocal feedback when you start writing. Track your progress by the number of interactions and responses you receive from authors and other readers.
Welcoming Practices

Offering links to starter prompts or recommended must-read fics.

New members are often welcomed by sharing curated resources to help them engage with the fanfiction culture and get inspiration.

Inviting new writers to participate in group challenges like Big Bangs.

This encourages newcomers to contribute and feel included in the collaborative creative spirit of the community.
Beginner Mistakes

Not tagging stories with ships or triggers.

Always use detailed tags to respect readers’ preferences and community norms.

Posting without proofreading or beta reading.

Seek beta readers or review your work carefully before posting to maintain quality and positive reception.
Pathway to Credibility

Tap a pathway step to view details

Facts

Regional Differences
North America

North American fans often engage heavily on Tumblr and AO3, participating in large-scale challenges like Big Bangs and prompt memes.

Europe

European fans sometimes prefer smaller, regional discussion groups and local conventions, with a slightly stronger focus on meta-analysis and academic-style critique.

Misconceptions

Misconception #1

All Supernatural fanfiction is romantic or ships-centered.

Reality

While many stories explore relationships, the community also produces extensive non-romantic work focused on action, mystery, and character depth.

Misconception #2

The fandom only exists while the TV show airs.

Reality

Supernatural fanfiction has sustained a vibrant and growing community even after the series finale, with ongoing creative reinterpretation and preservation of the show's lore.

Misconception #3

The fanfiction community is hostile or toxic due to ship wars.

Reality

Although passionate debates happen, many community members prioritize respectful discussion and create supportive spaces for diverse viewpoints.

Feedback

How helpful was the information in Supernatural Fanfiction?