Fantasy Writers bubble
Fantasy Writers profile
Fantasy Writers
Bubble
Skill
Professional
Fantasy Writers are a global community of authors and enthusiasts focused on creating, sharing, and critiquing stories set in imaginati...Show more
General Q&A
The Fantasy Writers community centers on creating stories set in magical worlds, with an emphasis on worldbuilding, imaginative storytelling, and genre-specific craft.
Community Q&A

Summary

Key Findings

Magic Hierarchies

Opinion Shifts
Fantasy writers deeply debate hard vs. soft magic systems, with these views marking insider credibility and influencing story critiques more than just style preferences.

Peer Rituals

Community Dynamics
Frequent critique circle participation and workshops are social rites that build trust and status, creating a cycle of mutual dependency unique to this bubble.

Plot Identity

Identity Markers
Self-identifying as a pantser or plotter signals more than writing style; it's a core social identity shaping how members relate and judge creative processes.

Complexity Defense

Insider Perspective
Insiders share a subtle, collective mission to defend fantasy's complexity against outsider dismissal, reinforcing community pride and validating intricate worldbuilding efforts.
Sub Groups

Aspiring Fantasy Writers

Writers new to the genre seeking feedback, resources, and community support.

Published Fantasy Authors

Professionals focused on networking, marketing, and advanced craft discussions.

Fanfiction & Fandom Writers

Writers who create fantasy stories within established universes or fandoms.

Worldbuilders

Enthusiasts dedicated to the craft of creating detailed fantasy worlds and lore.

Critique Circles

Groups focused on exchanging detailed feedback and manuscript critiques.

Statistics and Demographics

Platform Distribution
1 / 4
Reddit
22%

Reddit hosts highly active subreddits (e.g., r/FantasyWriters) dedicated to sharing, critiquing, and discussing fantasy writing, making it a central online hub for this community.

Reddit faviconVisit Platform
Discussion Forums
online
Discord
15%

Discord servers provide real-time chat, critique circles, and writing sprints, fostering close-knit, interactive communities for fantasy writers.

Discord faviconVisit Platform
Discussion Forums
online
Niche Forums
10%

Independent writing forums (e.g., Mythic Scribes, SFFWorld) offer focused, long-form discussion and critique tailored to fantasy writers.

Discussion Forums
online
Gender & Age Distribution
MaleFemale55%45%
13-1718-2425-3435-4445-5455-6465+5%25%30%20%12%6%2%
Ideological & Social Divides
Lore KeepersBoundary ExplorersWorkshop EldersWorldview (Traditional → Futuristic)Social Situation (Lower → Upper)
Community Development

Insider Knowledge

Terminology
VillainAntagonist

The term 'villain' presumes evil intent, but insiders use 'antagonist' to refer to any character or force opposing the protagonist, reflecting diverse narrative roles.

SidekickCompanion

Casual readers say 'sidekick,' often implying a secondary helper, but fantasy writers use 'companion' to give these characters more agency and importance in the story.

BattleEncounter

Casual observers call combat scenes 'battles,' while fantasy writers use 'encounter' to include all types of confrontations, whether social, magical, or physical.

Mythical CreaturesFauna

Outsiders refer generally to 'mythical creatures,' but insiders use 'fauna' to include all living beings in their world, focusing on ecological and cultural roles.

Magic WandFocus

Outsiders refer to 'magic wand' as a generic magical tool, but insiders use 'focus' to describe any object that channels magic, broadening the concept beyond traditional wands.

Medieval SettingLow Fantasy

Casual observers label fantasy worlds with medieval elements as simply 'medieval,' whereas writers distinguish such settings as 'low fantasy,' indicating worlds with minimal magic and realistic elements.

HeroProtagonist

Outsiders use 'hero' to describe the main character, but fantasy writers prefer 'protagonist' to avoid assumptions about morality or role, as protagonists can be morally complex.

MagicSystem

Casual observers call all magical elements simply 'magic,' while fantasy writers refer to the underlying rules and structure as a 'magic system,' emphasizing consistent and logical frameworks that guide magical phenomena.

MapWorld Bible

Laypeople see a 'map' as just geography, but insiders use 'world bible' to cover extensive details of setting, history, and culture supporting consistent storytelling.

ElfHighborn

Outsiders use 'elf' broadly, but fantasy writers sometimes say 'highborn' to signify elves of noble lineage or particular societal status within the world.

Book SeriesSaga

Outsiders call multiple books a series, while insiders use 'saga' to emphasize epic scale and interconnected mythic storytelling across volumes.

DragonWyrm

While casual observers universally say 'dragon,' some fantasy writers use 'wyrm' to denote specific traditional or serpentine dragon archetypes.

Plot HoleContinuity Error

Casual observers say 'plot hole' to describe inconsistencies, but fantasy writers prefer 'continuity error' to highlight breaks in logical consistency within complex narratives.

Good vs. EvilMoral Conflict

Outsiders often simplify fantasy plots as 'good vs. evil,' but insiders refer to 'moral conflict' to highlight nuanced ethical dilemmas and character motivations.

Greeting Salutations
Example Conversation
Insider
May your muse never falter.
Outsider
What do you mean by that?
Insider
It's a wish for steady creativity, hoping your inspiration stays strong so your writing flows without blocks.
Outsider
Ah, that’s a lovely sentiment for writers!
Cultural Context
This greeting conveys mutual encouragement common among fantasy writers, emphasizing ongoing inspiration as essential to the craft.
Inside Jokes

"That’s so pantser!"

A humorous jab among fantasy writers aimed at someone who flies by the seat of their pants, writing without a plan, often leading to chaotic storylines that require heavy rewriting.

"Beware the info-dump monster"

A playful warning about overly long exposition sections that can bog down the story and bore readers, as if a monster devours good pacing.
Facts & Sayings

Hard magic vs. soft magic

A common debate about how detailed and rule-bound a magic system is within a story; 'hard' magic has clear, logical rules while 'soft' magic is more mysterious and less defined.

Pantser vs. plotter

Describes a writer’s approach: 'pantsers' write by the seat of their pants without detailed planning, while 'plotters' meticulously outline their story before writing.

Info-dump

Refers to a large block of exposition that delivers background information, often seen as a risky writing choice that can disrupt narrative flow.

The write stuff

A playful phrase used to encourage or compliment someone’s writing efforts.
Unwritten Rules

Don’t overwhelm the reader with info-dumps immediately.

Revealing world details slowly maintains mystery and engagement rather than frontloading too much exposition.

Respect fellow writers’ work and offer constructive feedback.

Collaborative critique is valued over harsh criticism to build trust and help improve each other’s writing.

Balance originality with recognizable fantasy elements.

Innovating while adhering to some genre conventions helps readers connect while experiencing fresh narratives.

Avoid giving away plot twists prematurely.

Maintaining suspense is key to reader immersion; spoilers can alienate fans and diminish story impact.
Fictional Portraits

Evelyn, 29

Editorfemale

Evelyn is an emerging fantasy writer from Ireland who balances writing with her editorial job, and she participates actively in online critique groups.

CreativityCommunity supportAuthenticity
Motivations
  • Improving her craft through feedback
  • Networking with other fantasy writers
  • Exploring new storytelling techniques
Challenges
  • Finding time to write consistently
  • Dealing with imposter syndrome
  • Connecting with niche audiences effectively
Platforms
Fantasy writing forumsDiscord critique groupsTwitter threads
worldbuildingMC (main character)plot arcsmagic system

Rajesh, 42

Literature Professormale

Rajesh is an experienced fantasy novelist and academic from India who integrates scholarly analysis with creative writing within the global fantasy community.

Intellectual rigorRespect for traditionInclusivity
Motivations
  • Merging academic and creative perspectives
  • Mentoring emerging writers
  • Deepening genre understanding
Challenges
  • Balancing academic work with fiction writing
  • Keeping up with changing literary trends
  • Addressing cultural biases in fantasy genres
Platforms
Scholarly forumsWriting retreatsLinkedIn groups
subcreationnarrative framingmythopoeia

Maya, 19

Studentfemale

Maya is a college student and new fantasy writer from Brazil who uses the bubble for inspiration, learning, and community support.

GrowthCommunityOriginality
Motivations
  • Learning storytelling basics
  • Finding encouragement and feedback
  • Connecting with diverse voices
Challenges
  • Overwhelmed by established authors’ standards
  • Limited access to publishing resources
  • Breaking out of cliché influences
Platforms
Reddit fantasy writing subredditsTikTok fan communitiesDiscord beginner writing groups
MCfanficworldbuildingbeta readers

Insights & Background

Historical Timeline
Main Subjects
People

J.R.R. Tolkien

Considered the father of modern high fantasy, his Middle-earth legendarium set the template for worldbuilding and epic narrative.
High Fantasy PioneerWorldbuilding StandardPhilologist Author
J.R.R. Tolkien
Source: Image / PD

George R.R. Martin

Broke conventions with gritty, politically complex epic fantasy in A Song of Ice and Fire, influencing a darker, more character-driven subgenre.
Grimdark OriginatorComplex PoliticsTV Adaptation

Brandon Sanderson

Renowned for intricate magic systems and prolific output, he’s both a bestselling author and a mentor in the writing community.
Magiccraft GuruProlific WorldbuilderPedagogical Writer

Ursula K. Le Guin

Her Earthsea cycle introduced nuanced themes of power, balance and identity, expanding the genre’s literary scope.
Literary FantasyPhilosophical ToneCultural Critic

Patricia A. McKillip

Famed for lyrical prose and dreamlike settings, she exemplifies the poetic tradition in fantasy storytelling.
Poetic ProseDreamscape WorldClassic Enchanter

Terry Pratchett

Blended satire and fantasy in the Discworld series, showcasing how the genre can explore society with humor.
Comic FantasySatirical EdgeLong-Running Series

Robert Jordan

His Wheel of Time series became a benchmark for sprawling epic fantasy and complex ensemble casts.
Epic SagaEnsemble CastMythic Scope

N. K. Jemisin

Her groundbreaking themes of oppression and identity, plus innovative narrative structures, have reshaped contemporary fantasy.
Inclusive FantasyInnovative StructureHugo Winner

Patrick Rothfuss

Known for the Kingkiller Chronicle’s lyrical style and deep character focus, he’s a benchmark for modern epic fantasy.
Lyric ProseMystery DrivenCult Following

C.S. Lewis

His Chronicles of Narnia fused allegory and fantasy for generations of readers, pioneering accessible children’s fantasy.
Allegorical FantasyChildren’s ClassicChristian Themes
1 / 3

First Steps & Resources

Get-Started Steps
Time to basics: 2-4 weeks
1

Read Foundational Fantasy Works

1-2 weeksBasic
Summary: Immerse yourself in classic and modern fantasy novels to understand genre conventions and styles.
Details: Reading widely within the fantasy genre is a crucial first step for any aspiring fantasy writer. Start by selecting a mix of classic and contemporary fantasy novels—these might include epic sagas, urban fantasy, or magical realism. Pay attention to how authors build worlds, develop characters, and handle magic systems. Take notes on what resonates with you and what doesn't. This exposure will help you internalize genre expectations, common tropes, and innovative storytelling techniques. Beginners often struggle with identifying what makes fantasy distinct from other genres; reading a variety of works helps clarify this. To deepen your engagement, try annotating passages that inspire you or keeping a reading journal. Evaluate your progress by reflecting on your ability to discuss key themes, styles, and authors with others. This foundational knowledge will inform your own writing and help you participate meaningfully in community discussions.
2

Join Fantasy Writing Communities

1-3 daysBasic
Summary: Register and introduce yourself in online fantasy writing forums or local writing groups.
Details: Engaging with other fantasy writers is essential for learning, motivation, and feedback. Look for online forums, social media groups, or local meetups dedicated to fantasy writing. When joining, read the community guidelines and introduce yourself with a brief background and your interests in fantasy. Participate in discussions, ask questions, and offer encouragement to others. Beginners often feel intimidated or fear their work isn't good enough; remember that most communities are welcoming to newcomers and value fresh perspectives. Avoid lurking too long—active participation accelerates learning. This step is important for building a support network, finding critique partners, and staying motivated. You can gauge your progress by the number of meaningful interactions you have and your comfort level in sharing your thoughts or work.
3

Write a Short Fantasy Scene

2-4 hoursIntermediate
Summary: Draft a 500-1000 word scene featuring a magical element or mythical creature.
Details: Start your writing journey by creating a short, focused scene that incorporates a core fantasy element—such as magic, a mythical creature, or an invented setting. This exercise helps you move from theory to practice and gives you a manageable goal. Don't worry about perfection; focus on experimenting with voice, description, and worldbuilding. Common beginner challenges include overcomplicating the scene or getting stuck on details. To overcome this, set a timer (e.g., 30 minutes) and write without editing. Afterwards, review your work for clarity and imagination. This step is vital for building confidence and discovering your unique style. Progress is measured by completing the scene and reflecting on what you enjoyed or found difficult. Sharing this scene with others can provide valuable feedback and encouragement.
Welcoming Practices

Sharing draft excerpts in critique circles.

New writers share work early in trusted groups to receive feedback and feel part of the community.

Inviting newcomers to participate in NaNoWriMo challenges.

This annual event serves as a welcoming tradition that motivates writers through collective goals and camaraderie.
Beginner Mistakes

Starting with overly complex worldbuilding before story development.

Focus first on character and plot, adding world details organically to avoid getting stuck or confusing readers.

Ignoring the importance of revision and editing.

Accept that first drafts are rough and prioritize multiple revision rounds informed by critique to strengthen the narrative.
Pathway to Credibility

Tap a pathway step to view details

Facts

Regional Differences
North America

North American fantasy writers often emphasize diverse representation and experimental forms like urban fantasy, reflecting multicultural societies.

Europe

European fantasy frequently draws heavily from medieval history and folklore, with a focus on epic and high fantasy traditions.

Misconceptions

Misconception #1

Fantasy writing is just escapism and lacks depth.

Reality

While fantasy offers imaginative settings, many works explore complex themes like morality, politics, and identity with rich, layered storytelling.

Misconception #2

All fantasy stories use the same tired tropes and cliches.

Reality

Contemporary fantasy writers actively challenge traditional conventions, creating diverse characters and innovative plots to refresh the genre.

Misconception #3

Fantasy writers only write about dragons and wizards.

Reality

The genre spans a broad spectrum—from urban fantasy and magical realism to epic and dark fantasy—featuring unique magic systems, cultures, and conflicts.
Clothing & Styles

Convention badges and fantasy-themed shirts

Many fantasy writers display their community affiliation or favorite works via badges and t-shirts at gatherings, signaling their membership and enthusiasm.

Feedback

How helpful was the information in Fantasy Writers?